DIY all-natural eye-emphasizing mascara

After learning more about how to appropriately formulate skincare and beauty products, I no longer recommend this DIY all-natural eye-emphasizing mascara and have removed the recipe. My concern is with proper preservation of the formula to prevent bacteria growth.

As we live and learn, our thoughts, actions, and work evolve — I hope you understand! And I hope you will keep my concern in mind if you discover other DIY eye makeup recipes.

But don’t worry! I’ve tested A LOT of natural mascaras to find the very best for you.

Read more about my hunt for the best natural mascara, and which ones came out on top! I’m talking volume, definition, and long-lasting performance without any unhealthy chemicals adding to your body burden.


Get Your Copy

Last Post

Understanding egg cartons

Next Post

Kombucha 101

Share Your Thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Is there any way to make this waterproof? We live in Fl and everything runs here even without tears!

  2. Looks awesome! I have been wanting to make my own too, can you use this as liquid eyeliner too?

  3. How do you get the old store bought mascara out of the tube? or can you buy clean empty tubes to use?

  4. DOH!!! Just went back and read article again and found the answer to my own question! 😛

  5. Hmm unfortunately I don’t think it is. I always wash my face before working out but it washes of easily and is definitely not waterproof.

  6. Hi, Hannah. Probably – and to be honest, I tried. But it was too much to heat the wax and try to mix in the aloe – I couldn’t get it to the right consistency and I think one time it may have burned! I see how adding wax would be easier for coconut oil based mascaras. If you give it a go and it works out, please let me know!

  7. I have bulk activated charcoal. Do you know what the measurement is of the powder in 10 capsules? Thanks!

    Also, like Bryanna, I’m curious if this would work as an eyeliner (before I buy the empty eyeliner bottle). Thank you! =]

  8. I’m wondering why this did not work for me. I had all the ingredients on hand except the empty mascara tube. I do have a mascara wand so I tried to apply it directly from the shot glass that I mixed all the ingredients in. The black mixture does not get on my lashes. Mostly just splatters around my eye. It seems too liquidey. Oh well, on to the next experiment. Thanks for the recipe, though. Glad it works for you.

  9. Jenna, I don’t know why it didn’t work for you. I just used charcoal, aloe vera gel, and betonite clay. I didn’t measure out 10 capsules because mine is in bulk, so I’m not sure how much I put in. The consistency was gooey perfect and it stuck to my eyelashes. Maybe try putting more charcoal in?
    BTW, this is a great DIY. I don’t wear mascara just because who-knows-what’s-in-it. But now I have my own! Thanks!

  10. How did you come up with the idea to add bentonite clay? I can’t wait to try this and will report back with my results. Thank you!

  11. Anyone know if each of these ingredients are safe to use on the eyes? I’d really like to try this but I haven’t had much luck coming up with a conclusive answer based on the research I did.

  12. Well, I tried it as written and got a clump. I tried to loosen it with a bit of fractionated coconut oil and a tad more aloe vera, but no go. It felt exactly like jello in my fingers, to give you an idea of the consistency. For the heck of it I smeared it on my brush and used it…almost no change at all. What DID work, however, was squeezing out a drop of aloe, running my brush through it, then rolling it in the charcoal. Nice and long.

  13. I had a really hard time with the recipe above. It was so clumpy after first trying to mix it. I added a bunch of aloe but it wouldn’t stick to my eyelashes. I am a blonde so I could really tell.

    I tried the suggestion by Andreamerida and that did not work for me. I also tried adding more charcoal but it didn’t work either. Before giving up, I added more clay and slowly it began to stick to my eyelashes more and more. I do not have exact measurements since it was a process of adding more of this then more of that.

  14. I just tried to make this. It turned out to be dry and chalky. Can you post a video of you making this?

    I used exactly what the recipe called for and it was dry. So I read what Andreamerida said and added a little more aloe vera and coconut oil, it made it a little more moist but would not stick on my eyelashes.

    Any suggestions?

  15. I made this mascara and it looks just like mascara when applied. However, after about an hour or so it no longer looks like I’m wearing mascara and it seems to have rubbed off around my eyes. What could I do to solve this?

  16. My attempt was way too liquidy, and the recipe above made far more than would fit in the mascara tube I bought using the link above, so I wasted a lot of it. I’m guessing more clay and charcoal would improve the mixture, but my eyes were also rather itchy the days I wore it, so I’m not sure if it irritated my eyes, or what.

  17. Activated charcoal makes my eyes feel cold and irritated, like fumes from the fire they used to produce the product maybe? I just use black oxide and no sensitivity at all. Honestly, I think it’s safer than the charcoal, and both fall under a ‘dirt’ umbrella anyways. Vegi edible glycerin with the clay and tint works too, and is thicker.

  18. Love this mascara! It works great for me! It was messy filling the tube but it was fairly easy to clean up! Thank you for posting this!

  19. Hi Nadia, I tried your recipe but it seems like the measurements are inaccurate. Somehow I got an extremely blobby consistency- it did NOT stick to my lashes. No matter how hard I tried I couldn’t get the recipe to work, I added more aloe Vera etc NOTHING. I think 10 capsules of activated charcoal is waaaay too much, but I don’t think that was the exact problem. It’s just that the ingredients did not bind properly due to inaccurate measurements. Kudos to those who could make it happen- I couldn’t. Nadia if you have any suggestions please let me know. Everything I made went down the drain, I feel terrible for the materials I wasted. :-\

  20. I have noticed different consistencies with aloe vera depending on the brand, and wonder if that is why some are thinner than others. I used lily of the desert brand, 5 capsules of charcoal, 1/8 tsp bentonite clay and a 1/4 tsp vitamin E(the 70000IU kind). The vitamin E is pretty thick and probably helped with the consistence. I put on one coat and then a second and they didn’t clump or run. Thank you for the wonderful recipe!!

  21. Awesome! Thanks so much for sharing that. Yes, I bet the brand does alter the consistency a bit which makes it hard.

  22. Tried to make this with fresh aloe harvested from my plant. It was really a pain to get into the bottle since I didn’t have a syringe (which wouldn’t have worked anyway because of the consistency, I blame the fresh aloe). Hard to apply but looks OK. I plan to experiment with the recipe and get it to work with the fresh aloe. Thanks so much for the recipe! I really like your blog!

  23. Hi! I have just made this and I find it flakes off my lashes very easily. It doesn’t smudge – it’s not a liquid issue. Do you think it’s that there isn’t enough aloe or should I add more bentonite clay to firm things up?!

  24. Thanks Nadia! I just made this mascara and am so pleased to have a nontoxic alternative that looks natural and great! From the posts I read above I get the feeling the type of aloe vera might make a difference-I used ‘Lily of the Desert aloe vera gel-inner filet dietary supplement’ from my natural food store and the consistency was perfect when following your recipe. I made sure to shake the bottle really well first because otherwise mostly liquid pours out and wouldn’t give the right consistency. Thanks again for sharing this wonderful diy mascara recipe!

  25. I cant use aloe -allergic to everything….nothing nut based or coconut oil and vitamin E wouldn’t be an option since most of it is derived from soy another allergy-I was just wondering if you had any other suggestions for what I could replace the aloe with?

  26. For everyone getting clumps, try to just make sure you add the bentonite clay AFTER mixing the aloe and charcoal a bit, it really helps. I also added a capsule of vitamin E as a preservative and some Rosehip essential oil for…my love of Rosehip oil. ;p The addition of a little oil seemed to kind of smooth everyone out a little better without compromising the staying power. Another pro-tip: DEFINITELY get a syringe. I tried lots of silly experiments to almost no avail, a syringe definitely necessity to get your mascara in the tube, like, at all. However, the tiny bit I was able to get into my tube is great, I’m in love! This is an awesome recipe, thank you for saving my irritated eyes (and wallet)!

  27. When you add the clay, do you add the powder directly or mix it with water to make clay first? Thanks x

  28. I’m giving this one a try I made one mascara and its to oily I get oil all over my eye area so wish me good luck

  29. Made it for the 2nd time yesterday. Used Fruit of the Earth gel from amazon. Used 4t aloe, 6 charcoal caps & a scant 1/4 t bentonite, & a few drops of Vitamin E. Used a little 5 oz Anchor Hocking glass which made mixing easier. Also used a 1ml syringe (from the vet). It is tiny, but fits all the way down into the tube enabling filling at the bottom first, which is a problem for me. Using a narrow glass also makes it easier to fill the syringe. It might could have been a bit thinner, but works great.
    And ladies, check out the eyelash serum recipes…..they really DO work. Be patient, takes a few months.
    I also use the castor oil to remove eye makeup.

  30. I made your mascara I like it real well I use the only thing with it is sometimes I get coon eyes from using ,do u have any sugeastion on this .thank u for sharing this with me .

  31. I wonder if you can thin the mixture with contact solution the way you can thin (revive) commercial mascara. Maybe this might help those having thickness issues…

  32. well, this didn’t work for me. I have naturally curled eye lashes and blond hair. I tried (oh I tried, some 45 minutes!) to apply this mixture to my eyelashes and it just wouldn’t stick to the hair! At all! Forget “clumping”, “falling off” or “smearing” – it just didn’t color my hair.
    Eventually I started over and applied literally chunks of the mass on my eyelashes and the brushed through, then did it two more times – now I got it lightly shaded a shade darker and it covers 1/3rd of my eyelashes…

  33. thanks so much for this awesome idea! i tried several different variations of the coconut oil based recipe and never had much luck. excited to try this one soon 🙂

  34. I tried to make this mascara and I really like it 🙂 of course it is not as good looking as mascara from shop, but it is natural and safe. My eyes dont get red and not paining! I am so happy 🙂

  35. We in India make mascara by lighting a small earthenware bowl filled with either mustard oil or gingelly oil using a cotton wick. Another slightly bigger earthenware bowl is kept inverted on top of the flame to enable the soot to deposit .The soot is gently collected on a sheet of paper and transferred into a tiny sliver box . Then a small amount of clarified butter ( and a tiny bit of camphor which is optional ) is added and properly mixed and then lighted . When the flame has nearly but not totally died down this silver container is plunged in cool water and immediately removed and the excess water shaken out. Now the mascara is ready for use.

  36. Aloe Vera Gel actually is a very good clear mascara. Even though it has a sort of greenish tint, it is very good for dark lashes. I’m not sure about blonde lashes, or dirty blonde, because I have dark brown hair, but I think it might work. All you have to do is purchase or clean out a mascara container. Then add castor oil( it adds more volume to your eyelashes) and aloe vera gel. The castor oil helps you achieve a more voluminous look and the aloe vera gel helps your lashes grow longer. This is very very healthy, and I strongly approve it. This is also great for a natural kind of look and for tweens (10-12) who want to have beautiful healthy lashes. 🙂

  37. Very responsible of you to take it down! I never even saw it was just browsing curiously. But there are a lot of “Diy’s” and “beauty hacks” that are so harmful and toxic it kills me every time I see a new one pop up! Your integrity is greatly appreciated and admirable 🙂

  38. Hi Tiffany. May I ask specifically why you can’t read it? I’ve been having some technical issues and knowing exactly why you’re unable to read it would be very helpful to me so I can fix the problem! Thank you 🙂

  39. Hello Nadia,
    Last months I spentots of time in research for healthy honemade mascara. Of which engredients were your concerns? Isn’t it enough to use shea butter, cocnut oil or the vitemin E in order to get an antimicrobical effect?
    Many thanks 🙂